The old hag
LegendSeen: Room 5
Said to stand at the foot of the bed. From a radio listicle; no witness named.
Country house or manor · You can stay here
Old Hellaby Lane, Hellaby, Rotherham
Hellaby Hall is a Grade II* listed manor house near Rotherham, built around 1690 for the merchant Ralph Fretwell. It was derelict and partly gutted by fire when it was listed in 1987, and it's now an 89-bedroom hotel in the BW Signature Collection. A 2024 Hits Radio list of haunted places says activity is reported in ten bedrooms: an "old hag" at the foot of the bed in Room 5 and a strangling feeling in Room 36. No guest is named. You can book a room.

The house is well documented: its listing, its builder and its later owners are on record. The ghost stories aren't. They come from a radio station's list of haunted places, which names Rooms 5 and 36 but gives no guest, date or original source. The hotel doesn't mention them.
The bedrooms the stories are told about aren't old rooms. The listing says the interior was vandalised and partly gutted by fire, so today's bedrooms are modern rebuilds, not 17th-century rooms. A strangling feeling in sleep is also a common description of sleep paralysis.
What we checked:Documented history × 6Unverified × 4See each claim
Seen: Room 5
Said to stand at the foot of the bed. From a radio listicle; no witness named.
Seen: Room 36
Guests are said to feel a strangling sensation while asleep. No witness named.
Seen: The attic, seen from outside
Said to appear in photographs of the hall. None has been found.
In 2024 Hits Radio's list of the most haunted places in South Yorkshire said paranormal activity had been reported in ten of the hotel's bedrooms. It didn't say which ten, or who reported it.
The same list says an "old hag" is said to stand at the end of the bed in Room 5. No guest, date or description of her is given.
Guests in Room 36 are said to have felt a strangling sensation while they slept. Again, no one is named.
Photographs of the hall are said to sometimes show a figure standing at the attic window. We haven't found any such photograph published.
We haven’t confirmed this with the hotel yet.
Where guests are said to feel a strangling sensation in their sleep (radio listicle, no witness named).
Ask when you book: nothing is guaranteed until the hotel agrees.
We haven’t confirmed this with the hotel yet.
Where an "old hag" is said to stand at the foot of the bed (radio listicle, no witness named).
Ask when you book: nothing is guaranteed until the hotel agrees.
Hellaby Hall was built between 1688 and 1692 for Ralph Fretwell, a merchant who had set up sugar plantations in Barbados from 1653, became a Quaker in 1671 and came home to England in the late 1680s. The house has a limestone front of five bays, two storeys, an attic and a basement, with a shaped gable and Baroque kneelers. A rear wing was added in the 18th century.
The hall passed to Fretwell's daughter Dorothea and down her line. In 1767 a marriage brought it to the Eden baronets, who let it to the Clarke family, gentleman farmers, for about fifty years from the early 1800s. The Edens sold it in 1869 to Edward Morrell, and Thomas Edward Morrell ran a horse stud here.
After Edward Cecil Plumpton Morrell died in a shooting accident in 1922, the hall was sold to Percy Carnelly. His family lived here until about 1975.
After 1975 the hall passed through a series of companies. When Historic England listed it at Grade II* in 1987 it was derelict, vandalised and partly gutted by fire, though panelled plaster ceilings and a grand staircase survived. It was later restored and converted to a hotel. It now has 89 bedrooms and trades as Hellaby Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection.
1692
Ralph Fretwell completes the hall
1767
Passes to the Edens
1869
Sold to the Morrells
1922
The Carnellys buy the hall
1 April 1987
Listed Grade II*, derelict
What each story about the Hellaby Hall Hotel rests on. A published account shows that someone reported an experience, not what caused it.
Hellaby Hall was built between 1688 and 1692 for Ralph Fretwell, a merchant with sugar plantations in Barbados who had become a Quaker.
A marriage brought the hall to the Eden baronets.
The Edens sold the hall to Edward Morrell, and the Morrells ran a horse stud here.
The hall was sold to Percy Carnelly, whose family lived here until about 1975.
When it was listed Grade II*, the hall was derelict, vandalised and partly gutted by fire.
Paranormal activity has been reported in ten of the hotel's bedrooms.
A radio listicle; it doesn't say which rooms, who reported it or where the figure comes from.
An old hag stands at the end of the bed in Room 5.
Listicle only; no guest or date. The bedrooms were rebuilt after the fire damage.
Guests in Room 36 have felt a strangling sensation while they slept.
Listicle only; no guest or date. A feeling of pressure or choking in sleep is a common description of sleep paralysis.
The Hellaby Hall Hotel is said to be haunted by the old hag, the strangler and the figure at the attic window. Reported activity includes apparition, visual, physical contact.
We haven't confirmed it with the hotel yet. Ask when you book: nothing is guaranteed until the hotel agrees.
We haven't confirmed it with the hotel yet. Ask when you book: nothing is guaranteed until the hotel agrees.
The most reported areas are: Room 5, Room 36.
A 2024 Hits Radio list says activity is reported in ten of its bedrooms, naming an old hag in Room 5 and a strangling feeling in Room 36. It names no guests and gives no source, and the hotel doesn't tell these stories itself.
Both are hotel bedrooms, so you can ask for them when you book. We haven't checked whether the hotel will guarantee a room number.
It was built between 1688 and 1692 for Ralph Fretwell, with an 18th-century rear wing. It's listed Grade II*. The interior was badly damaged by fire before the house was restored as a hotel.
No guest accounts yet. If you've stayed here, yours could be the first.
Share your experiencePage last reviewed 21 November 2026.
Check room prices and availability for your dates.
An old farmhouse inn high on the Woodhead Pass near Penistone, said to have once held the bodies of travellers who died on the moors. In 2004 the landlady told the Huddersfield Examiner about a strange smell, footsteps and objects moving in the bar.
Check pricesA 17th-century country house on the edge of Sheffield, a hotel since 1976. Its White Lady, a governess said to have been killed by the squire, is linked to the Lord John Darcy Suite, which the hotel sells as a ghost package.
Check prices
A lonely 17th-century inn on the moors west of Sheffield, built as a house for the Worrall family and an inn since about 1771. Its bar is said to be haunted by a grey lady, though no story or witness goes with her.
Check prices